top of page

The Great Bookshelf: The Books That Stay With Us

Writer: Erin Tudryn
Erin Tudryn
Nov 3
10 min read

About two years ago, during Lent, I decided to put my phone down. I thought it would be a relatively simple sacrifice. I would spend less time scrolling, be a little more intentional with my days, and perhaps emerge from the experience feeling a bit more present. What I didn't anticipate was just how difficult it would be.

It turns out that when you remove something that has quietly occupied nearly every spare moment of your day, you are left with a surprising amount of time—and, more importantly, space. Space to think, space to be still, and space to rediscover the things that bring you genuine fulfillment.

During that time, I began filling the hours I once spent scrolling with reading. And somewhere along the way, I was reminded of something I think we often forget: there is a particular kind of nourishment that comes from reading a good book. Not just the kind that entertains you or gives you something to pass the time, but the kind that challenges your thinking, introduces you to new ideas, and leaves you looking at the world a little differently.

One of the books I read during that season was The Three Ordinary Voices of God by Matthew Kelly. In it, Kelly discusses our intellectual needs and the importance of feeding our minds. Reading is one of the ways we can do this. He also shares a practice of his own that I found particularly meaningful: he keeps a special shelf of books that have deeply touched him. These are books he can return to whenever he needs inspiration, encouragement, or a reminder of something important.

I loved this idea.

So, naturally, I decided to create my own Great Bookshelf.

And really, who doesn't love talking about their favorite books? The books they recommend to everyone, the ones they lend out (sometimes reluctantly), and the ones they find themselves thinking about long after they've finished reading them. There is something special about discussing the books that have left an impression on us. They often reveal a little about who we are, what we value, and the people we are becoming.

That is what this post is about: my Great Bookshelf. A growing collection of books that have, in one way or another, left their mark on me. I'm excited to share them, and perhaps introduce you to a few that you haven't discovered yet.

But before I get into the books themselves, I want to establish one thing.

I have a terrible habit of wanting to see the finished product before I've even begun. When I start something, I want to know what it will look like, how long it will take, and when I can check it off my list. I like the satisfaction of completion. And if you are anything like me, the idea of creating your own Great Bookshelf might sound like a fun little project to tackle this weekend.

But I think that would miss the point entirely.

Kelly mentions that his own Great Bookshelf contains approximately thirty books. Thirty books that have earned their place there over time. And that is an important distinction: the Great Bookshelf isn't simply a collection of books you've read, nor is it a list of books that everyone says you should read. It is something much more personal.

So, what qualifies a book to make the shelf?

It has to move you. It has to touch your soul in some way. It has to leave something behind.

For me, it is a book that I continue to think about long after I've put it down. Maybe it challenged an idea I had always accepted, gave language to something I had struggled to articulate, introduced me to a perspective I had never considered, or simply reminded me of something I had forgotten. Sometimes, it is a book that I find myself recommending months or even years later. Other times, it is one I know I will need to revisit at another stage of my life.

Not every good book belongs on the Great Bookshelf. And that is perfectly fine.

Some books are enjoyable in the moment. Some are informative, entertaining, or beautifully written. But the books that earn a permanent place on this shelf are the ones that become a part of you in some way. They are the ones that linger.

I also think there is something beautiful about allowing this collection to grow slowly. There is no deadline, no quota, and no pressure to fill every inch of the shelf. In fact, I hope it takes years to fill. Because the goal isn't to accumulate thirty books. The goal is to live a life in which I am continually learning, questioning, discovering, and allowing myself to be changed by what I read.

So, consider this an invitation to build your own Great Bookshelf, too. Don't worry about how many books are on it or how long it takes to fill. Start with the one book you can't stop thinking about.

And perhaps, every now and then, put your phone down long enough to find another.





My Great Bookshelf:


Live in Love by Lauren Akins

Lauren Akins has been one of my role models for years. I have always admired the way she carries herself. Her friends describe her as someone who radiates sunshine, and I think that is exactly what I have always loved about her.

In her memoir, Lauren gives us a glimpse into her story as a Christian girl navigating today's world while remaining true to her faith and values. We follow her through finding her purpose, falling in love, becoming a wife, navigating life alongside a country music star, and eventually becoming a mother.

For me, this book was a little light. It reminded me that the things I longed for—a loving marriage, a beautiful family, and a home filled with love—were worth hoping for. It made me believe that my own beautiful family was out there, too.


The Great Gatsby by F. Scott FitzgeraldA literary classic, and one I believe everyone should read, especially in today's society. The Great Gatsby reminds us that the people we put on pedestals are not larger than life; they are human, too. I think it is a tragedy that feels even more relevant today than when I first read it over ten years ago.

Initially, I was drawn to the book because of my love for New York, but as I've gotten older, I've come to appreciate its deeper message: sometimes the things we think we want aren't worth having. We all have a green light we're reaching for, something we believe will finally make us happy. But sometimes, in our pursuit of it, we become blind to the beauty of what is already in front of us.

Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate

This is one of those books I wish I could read for the first time all over again. The story of this book, for me, begins before I even opened its pages. I was browsing a used bookstore when I stumbled upon a pile of free books sitting outside under a tarp. Among them was a hardcover copy of this book. I opened the cover, read the words Memphis, Tennessee, and immediately put it in my trunk.

Lisa Wingate weaves together historical fiction set in the 1930s and the present day. We follow Rill and her siblings as they fall victim to Georgia Tann's Tennessee Children's Home Society, while the present-day narrative reveals the lasting trauma and real-life consequences of Tann's actions.

There is one passage from this book that I have carried with me ever since I first read it: 

“much we may love the melody of a bygone day or imagine the song of a future one, we must dance within the music of today, or we will always be out of step, stumbling around in something that doesn’t suit the moment. I let go of the river’s song and found the music of that big house. I found room for a new life, a new mother who cared for me, and a new father who patiently taught me not only how to play music, but how to trust. He was as good a man as ever I’ve known.”

― Lisa Wingate, Before We Were Yours


It is a reminder I return to often: we can spend so much time longing for the past or dreaming about the future that we forget to live in the life unfolding right in front of us. There is something beautiful about learning to dance to the music of today.

  


The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson

When I first became interested in true crime, this was one of the books recommended to me. To my surprise, I found myself just as fascinated, if not more, by the architect behind the 1893 Chicago World's Fair than by H. H. Holmes, one of America's most infamous serial killers.

Erik Larson is a remarkable storyteller. He has a way of weaving historical events together with the suspense of a thriller, making even the smallest details feel captivating. The Devil in the White City is a perfect example of how fascinating history can be when told well.


Church of Cowards by Matt Walsh

In this book, Matt Walsh invites some serious self-reflection about how we approach church today. Do we treat it with the reverence it deserves, or have we become a little too comfortable? Walsh challenges the ways we have lowered our expectations of ourselves and others within the Church, reminding us that Jesus wasn't afraid to flip tables.

I picked up this book during my big Daily Wire phase and was surprised by just how much truth I found within its pages (even if I did feel a little called out). Sometimes we need a book that makes us uncomfortable, one that we accidentally take personally because perhaps there's something we need to hear.


The Three Ordinary Voices of God by Matthew Kelly

My mother-in-law gave me this book for Christmas, and I decided to save it for Lent. Little did I know that it would end up setting the tone for my entire Lenten season in 2024.

This book was a reminder that God doesn't always speak to us in grand gestures or extraordinary moments. Sometimes, His voice is found in the most ordinary parts of our everyday lives. Kelly explores the three ordinary voices of God and challenges readers to become more attentive to the ways God is speaking to them, even when they aren't necessarily listening.

One of the things I loved most about this book was how it encouraged me to slow down and become more intentional about my faith. It's so easy to get caught up in the busyness of everyday life that we forget to make room for God in it. We wait for some big moment, some unmistakable sign, or some extraordinary experience, when perhaps God has been speaking to us all along through the ordinary.

I think this is especially important during Lent, a season that calls us to step back, examine our lives, and make more room for Christ. This book encouraged me to do just that. It reminded me that growing in faith isn't always about doing something extraordinary. Sometimes, it's about learning to recognize God in the ordinary and being willing to respond.

If you're looking for a book to help you become more intentional in your relationship with God, I would absolutely recommend this one. It's a reminder that we don't have to go searching for extraordinary experiences to encounter God. We just have to learn to listen.


Love in Recovery by Rachel Killackey

I bought this book in Salt Lake City, Utah, after hearing Rachel Killackey speak at the SEEK 2025 conference. Love in Recovery dives into the healing of sexual trauma and examines the ways society and social media continue to perpetuate the age-old message that “sex sells.”

I personally loved this book, even when it was difficult to read. During a season of looking more deeply into my own past and personal struggles, it reminded me that I wasn't alone. More than anything, Love in Recovery is a beautiful reminder of God's endless grace and the depth of His love for us.



The Great Divorce by CS Lewis

I believe that, much like The Great Gatsby, this is a literary classic. Even in the quiet moments of life, I often find myself thinking about different elements of C.S. Lewis's The Great Divorce. My priest, who played such an important role in helping me find my way back to the Catholic Church, gave me one of his own copies. Because of that, the physical book holds just as much meaning to me as the words inside it.

In this imaginative story, we follow a group of ghosts who travel from a grey, dreary place toward the outskirts of Heaven. Along the way, we encounter different souls and the struggles, attachments, and choices that keep them from fully embracing Heaven. Lewis offers a thought-provoking reflection on human nature, sin, grace, and the choices we make. It's one of those books that stays with you long after you've turned the final page.


The Attachment Parenting Book by William SearsMD and Martha Sears MD

This book was gifted to me by someone who was such a wonderful source of support throughout my pregnancy. When she gave it to me at my mini baby shower, I knew I had to read it. As a first-time mom, it calmed so many of my nerves and gave me practical advice as I prepared to welcome my baby. I especially loved learning about the biology of mom, dad, and baby and better understanding the science behind attachment and bonding. It was such a fascinating and reassuring read during a season when I had so much to learn.


The Devil in Pew Number Seven by Rebecca Nichols Alonzo

I remember exactly where I was sitting in my Baba’s (my baby way of saying Baci) living room when Rebecca Nichols Alonzo’s episode of Dr. Phil came on television. I was mesmerized, glued to the box television as Rebecca spoke about forgiving the man who murdered her mother. I remember my mom taking me to Barnes & Noble almost immediately to buy The Devil in Pew Number Seven. This is probably the first book to earn a place on my Great Bookshelf.

Rebecca Nichols Alonzo tells the story of her father becoming a pastor in a small town and the events that forever changed her family. As she walks us through her childhood and the tragedy that ultimately took both of her parents, readers are left with one of the greatest lessons: the power of forgiveness. But what I love most about this book is its reminder that forgiveness is a journey. It can come in waves, and we don't have to force ourselves to arrive there before we're ready.


What books are on your great bookshelf?


Comments


bottom of page